Prop. 11: nomia currency generation (FAILED)

" Upon the success of a proposition, the creator of that prop. receives 10 silver coins for use in the nomia sub game"

Ten seems like a good round number, I also considered 20, but wanted to see what people think first.

This proposal doesn't take into account the number of failed proposals, which will result in spam. It's like having no Rule 2, since people no longer have to think about what they propose. As such, I must Vote: No.

That said, I would approve of something along the lines of...

"Any player with a positive or zero Nomic score shall receive a paycheck of 10 silver coins each time one of their proposals is passed."

...so feel free to resubmit it if you like.

Vote: No. What Mokina said.

Mokina wrote:This proposal doesn't take into account the number of failed proposals, which will result in spam. It's like having no Rule 2, since people no longer have to think about what they propose. As such, I must Vote: No.

That said, I would approve of something along the lines of...

"Any player with a positive or zero Nomic score shall receive a paycheck of 10 silver coins each time one of their proposals is passed."

...so feel free to resubmit it if you like.

I agree with Mokina on this one. I would Vote: Yes on the proposition if it was editted slightly, however in this form I am going to have to Vote: No

vote: no

see above

Vote: No. I agree that Mokina's edited one will work better.

should I just edit my post, or submit an amendment?

pyrodwarf wrote:should I just edit my post, or submit an amendment?

I believe you have to submit a new proposal entirely. You can't amend proposals that haven't passed yet.

what about a low negative number, like -5?

pyrodwarf wrote:what about a low negative number, like -5?

I would advise against this, since passing proposals at a low negative number will still allow you to return to a positive score. You can work your way out, but there shouldn't be too much leeway.

If people are more comfortable with -5, fair enough. Ultimately it's up to you.

No. Zero is better than -5. Vote NAY for the proposal in its current state.

While I do not agree with the proposal in it's current state, I wish to acknowledge my agreement with Mokina's proposed idea.

Vote: Nay

Vote: No I think success is the wrong word here.

Voting on this Proposal has ended

There is 1 Yea.
There are 10 Nays.

This Proposal has failed.